Extract from JD Supra's "Court Refuses to Allow EU Privacy Laws to Shield U.S. Company from Discovery Obligations"
A federal court in Michigan recently became the latest court to weigh in on the extent that litigants could rely on European Union data laws to shield them from producing documents in U.S. litigation. The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan held that despite restrictions on the disclosure of “private” data inherent in E.U. data law, a litigant in the United States was still required to comply with the discovery requirement of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure even if that necessitated production of documents and data stored on servers in the European Union.
As email communication and ESI have become ubiquitous in world commerce, the United States and the European Union have applied radically different default rules concerning its ownership and placed radically different default rules on their use in litigation. The European Union considers any email or ESI which contains a personal identifier, such as a name, to contain personal data. The EU Data Protection Directive (also known as Directive 95/46/EC) is a regulation adopted by the European Union to protect the privacy and protection of all personal data collected for or about citizens of the EU, especially as it relates to processing, using or exchanging such data.
As it relates to litigation, the EU Data Protection Directive forbids production of any emails or ESI without first identifying the individuals whose “personal data” is implicated and obtaining the consent to its disclosure. In practice, these rules dramatically reduce the exchange of documents between parties in European litigation.
I wanted a certification that separates me from my peers. Upon discovering CEDS, I was convinced this was exactly the type of distinction I had been seeking. Since achieving CEDS certification, I’ve noticed immediate recognition from my organization, colleagues, and current and prospective clients.They acknowledge they are more comfortable working with a person who has taken time to seek such certification. CEDS has certainly been worth the small investment and should continue to beget returns for years and years to come.
Andrew Bayer, CEDS
I get bombarded with all kinds of e-discovery stuff – news, blogs and whatnot. Let me tell you, you guys send the absolute best! I send it to all my partners and sales folks. I said, who are these guys? I have to get to know them better!
Kevin Glass, CEO
As a trial lawyer, day-to-day information processing is daunting for my client service. I’ve come to rely on ACEDS to keep me on the ‘edge’ of the curve on e-discovery. It’s a source I ‘ping’ ASAP.