Amazon moved to quash the subpoena in the hot tub murder case covered here last year. The grounds are novel: not only does Amazon assert a first amendment, freedom of speech right for the consumer/human speaker, but also for the search engine speaking through the Alexa voice interface.
Personal utterances in one’s home are protected speech, asserts Amazon, citing case after case where purchase history and book purchases were deemed protective. In addition, they cite Zhang v. Baidu.com Inc., 10 F. Supp. 3d 433, 435 (S.D.N.Y. 2014) regarding protection of ranked search results being deemed “constitutionally protected opinion.”
With a heightened standard of review due to the sensitivity of the first amendment issues, Amazon is hoping the State will not make their case and their commercial concern for privacy will not be impacted. Should the court not quash the subpoena, Amazon requests an in camera review.
According to Amazon, the recordings and transcripts of requests are not stored on the local device. Rather they and the responses of the search engine are stored on Amazon servers, servers that are not physically located in Arkansas.
I wanted a certification that separates me from my peers. Upon discovering CEDS, I was convinced this was exactly the type of distinction I had been seeking. Since achieving CEDS certification, I’ve noticed immediate recognition from my organization, colleagues, and current and prospective clients.They acknowledge they are more comfortable working with a person who has taken time to seek such certification. CEDS has certainly been worth the small investment and should continue to beget returns for years and years to come.
Andrew Bayer, CEDS
I get bombarded with all kinds of e-discovery stuff – news, blogs and whatnot. Let me tell you, you guys send the absolute best! I send it to all my partners and sales folks. I said, who are these guys? I have to get to know them better!
Kevin Glass, CEO
As a trial lawyer, day-to-day information processing is daunting for my client service. I’ve come to rely on ACEDS to keep me on the ‘edge’ of the curve on e-discovery. It’s a source I ‘ping’ ASAP.